exact 3 stages without precut

REAL INSTANCES

ACTUAL RESULTS

SCOOP SW RESULTS

SCOOP IMPROVEMENTS

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

#01

66

17,06%

8

60

8,76%

10

-6

-8,29%

2

#02

3

38,52%

2

2

7,79%

3

-1

-30,74%

1

#03

54

19,76%

6

49

11,57%

7

-5

-8,19%

1

#04

14

22,42%

2

14

22,42%

2

0

0,00%

0

#05

16

25,85%

4

14

15,26%

5

-2

-10,59%

1

#06

80

21,15%

6

68

7,23%

11

-12

-13,91%

5

#07

42

16,53%

4

39

10,11%

3

-3

-6,42%

-1

#08

96

18,82%

6

84

7,22%

12

-12

-11,60%

6

#09

6

25,71%

3

6

25,71%

3

0

0,00%

0

#10

73

19,10%

6

67

11,86%

9

-6

-7,24%

3

#11

71

28,27%

6

55

7,40%

14

-16

-20,87%

8

#12

29

22,71%

4

25

10,34%

4

-4

-12,37%

0

#13

36

29,64%

5

28

9,54%

10

-8

-20,10%

5

#14

16

26,24%

3

14

15,71%

5

-2

-10,54%

2

#15

8

20,15%

10

8

20,15%

10

0

0,00%

0

#16

12

17,45%

14

12

17,45%

10

0

0,00%

-4

#17

4

17,85%

11

4

17,85%

9

0

0,00%

-2

#18

8

15,01%

11

8

15,01%

8

0

0,00%

-3

#19

6

23,44%

9

6

23,44%

9

0

0,00%

0

#20

10

35,10%

5

8

18,88%

6

-2

-16,22%

1

#21

5

17,20%

4

5

17,20%

5

0

0,00%

1

#22

24

15,96%

7

23

12,30%

9

-1

-3,65%

2

#23

4

31,70%

5

4

31,70%

6

0

0,00%

1

#24

18

20,37%

8

16

10,42%

11

-2

-9,95%

3

#25

20

29,45%

8

18

21,61%

5

-2

-7,84%

-3

#26

8

44,83%

2

7

36,95%

2

-1

-7,88%

0

#27

7

32,31%

3

6

21,03%

4

-1

-11,28%

1

TOTAL

736

 

650

 

 

 -86

 

 

AVERAGE

24,17% 6 16,11% 7,11   -8,06% 1,11

exact 2 stages with precut

REAL INSTANCES

ACTUAL RESULTS

SCOOP SW RESULTS

SCOOP IMPROVEMENT

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

DISTINCT PANEL

WASTE

MOS

#28

73

6,63%

5

73

6,63%

6

0

0,00%

1

#29

10

11,07%

2

9

1,19%

2

-1

-9,88%

0

#30

91

10,29%

6

88

7,24%

8

-3

-3,06%

2

#31

85

13,74%

6

80

8,35%

8

-5

-5,39%

2

#32

177

4,58%

5

180

6,17%

5

3

1,59%

0

#33

189

6,32%

4

184

3,78%

4

-5

-2,55%

0

#34

124

6,09%

5

131

11,10%

6

7

5,02%

1

#35

221

10,29%

4

215

7,78%

4

-6

-2,50%

0

#36

33

18,51%

2

35

23,17%

2

2

4,66%

0

#37

17

14,70%

3

16

12,18%

5

-1

-2,52%

2

#38

23

30,62%

2

19

16,01%

2

-4

-14,61%

0

#39

3

21,68%

3

3

21,68%

3

0

0,00%

0

#40

12

9,03%

5

13

16,03%

4

1

7,00%

-1

#41

225

9,51%

6

226

9,91%

10

1

0,40%

4

#42

11

17,06%

2

11

17,06%

2

0

0,00%

0

#43

6

21,87%

2

6

21,87%

2

0

0,00%

0

#44

19

14,22%

3

19

14,22%

3

0

0,00%

0

#45

22

16,98%

2

20

8,68%

3

-2

-8,30%

1

#46

109

6,74%

3

106

4,10%

3

-3

-2,64%

0

#47

127

9,79%

5

129

11,19%

5

2

1,40%

0

#48

221

10,29%

4

215

7,78%

4

-6

-2,50%

0

#49

74

10,49%

5

76

12,85%

3

2

2,36%

-2

#50

415

10,43%

4

418

11,08%

9

3

0,64%

5

#51

104

12,14%

4

107

14,60%

6

3

2,46%

2

#52

98

8,79%

4

98

8,79%

8

0

0,00%

4

#53

102

7,40%

4

105

10,05%

7

3

2,65%

3

#54

108

5,88%

4

106

4,10%

3

-2

-1,78%

-1

#55

107

5,00%

4

106

4,10%

3

-1

-0,90%

-1

#56

123

5,30%

5

132

3,49%

6

9

-1,81%

1

#57

221

10,26%

4

215

7,76%

4

-6

-2,50%

0

#58

172

3,53%

5

174

4,64%

4

2

1,11%

-1

#59

60

12,82%

2

57

8,23%

2

-3

-4,59%

0

#60

61

10,29%

2

63

13,13%

2

2

2,85%

0

#61

62

7,52%

5

65

9,51%

6

3

1,99%

1

#62

60

13,49%

6

55

5,63%

9

-5

-7,86%

3

#63

49

12,02%

4

46

6,28%

7

-3

-5,74%

3

#64

34

11,99%

1

34

11,99%

1

0

0,00%

0

#65

75

13,77%

7

70

 

8

-5

 

1

#66

185

8,50%

5

183

7,50%

14

-2

-1,00%

9

#67

28

24,69%

4

24

28,49%

7

-4

3,80%

3

#68

5

16,56%

4

5

16,56%

4

0

0,00%

0

#69

2

23,54%

4

2

23,54%

2

0

0,00%

-2

TOTAL

3943

 

 

3919

 

 

-24

 

 

AVERAGE

 

12,01%

3,95

 

10,94%

4,90

 

-1,03%

0,95